Daily Knock #12: A locked dispensary

The log · set at Stillwater Sanatorium · played 7 November 2026

Four entries were made in the night book of the ward block. Three are true. One cannot be. Which?

  1. A21:30The porter locks the gate behind the milk cart.
  2. B21:50The sister collects the evening tray from the dispensary.
  3. C22:15The doctor signs the ward book at the bedside.
  4. D22:40The sister is seen putting bottles back on the dispensary shelves.

What we know

  • the ward to the dispensary: 4 minutes on foot.
  • the dispensary to the gatehouse: 9 minutes on foot.
  • the ward to the gatehouse: 11 minutes on foot.
  • The dispensary was locked from 22:00 to 23:30, and the only key was in the matron’s safe.
  • A line marked fixed comes from a signed or machine-stamped record, and is right.
Stuck? A hint

One rule says when a room could not be used. Check each line that uses that room.

Show the answer

Answer. Line D (22:40): The sister is seen putting bottles back on the dispensary shelves.

The dispensary was locked from 22:00 to 23:30, so the sister cannot have been in it at 22:40. Her visit at 21:50 was before it was locked.

Play the full case Today’s Daily Knock

Updated .