Daily Knock #18: Hot milk in the kitchen

The log · set at Hill House · played 13 November 2026

Four entries were made in the housekeeper’s book on the night before the storm. Three are true. One cannot be. Which?

  1. A19:30The nurse signs the nursery book: the child is asleep.fixed
  2. B19:33The cook says the nurse came down to the kitchen for hot milk.
  3. C19:40The cook slices the bread for the servants’ supper.
  4. D19:50The nurse takes the warm milk back up to the nursery.

What we know

  • the nursery to the kitchen: 6 minutes on foot.
  • the kitchen to the cellar: 3 minutes on foot.
  • the nursery to the cellar: 9 minutes on foot.
  • A line marked fixed comes from a signed or machine-stamped record, and is right.
Stuck? A hint

Only one person is in two places. How long is the walk between them, and how much time passed?

Show the answer

Answer. Line B (19:33): The cook says the nurse came down to the kitchen for hot milk.

The walk from the nursery to the kitchen is six minutes, and only three passed after the nurse signed the nursery book. She could not have been in the kitchen at 19:33.

Play the full case Today’s Daily Knock

Updated .