Daily Knock #2: The gate book and the boathouse
The log · set at Hill House · played 28 October 2026
Four entries were made in the house log on the night of the storm. Three of them are true. One cannot be. Which?
- A20:00The butler signs for the doctor’s bag at the front door.fixed
- B20:10The butler opens the gates for the doctor’s car.
- C20:50The gardener says he was locking up the boathouse.
- D21:10The gatehouse book is signed by the gardener, in ink.fixed
What we know
- the house to the gatehouse: 10 minutes on foot.
- the house to the boathouse: 15 minutes on foot.
- the gatehouse to the boathouse: 22 minutes on foot.
- A line marked fixed comes from a signed or machine-stamped record, and is right.
Stuck? A hint
Follow one person at a time. Who appears twice, and could they walk it in the time between?
Show the answer
Answer. Line C (20:50): The gardener says he was locking up the boathouse.
The gardener cannot walk from the boathouse to the gatehouse (22 minutes) in 20, and the gatehouse entry is signed, so the boathouse line is the wrong one. The butler’s two lines are exactly 10 minutes apart, which is the walk, so they just fit.
Updated .