Daily Knock #5: The lifts were off

The log · set at the Indigo Line · played 31 October 2026

Four entries were made in the station log at the end of the last night’s service. Three are true. One cannot be. Which?

  1. A23:10The turnstile counter stamps the last ticket of the night.fixed
  2. B23:35The cleaner rides the lift down to the platform with the mop cart.
  3. C23:55The guard rides the lift up to the ticket hall.
  4. D23:58The cleaner locks the depot door.

What we know

  • the ticket hall to the platform: 4 minutes on foot.
  • the platform to the depot: 6 minutes on foot.
  • the ticket hall to the depot: 9 minutes on foot.
  • The station lifts were switched off from 23:30 to 23:50 for the night service.
  • A line marked fixed comes from a signed or machine-stamped record, and is right.
Stuck? A hint

Look at the times against the rule. Is anything done by lift while the lifts are off?

Show the answer

Answer. Line B (23:35): The cleaner rides the lift down to the platform with the mop cart.

The lifts were off from 23:30 to 23:50, so the cleaner cannot have ridden one down at 23:35. The guard’s ride at 23:55 is after they came back on.

Play the full case Today’s Daily Knock

Updated .